Monday, March 23, 2009

She Audits Me, She Audits Me Not

Ah, Spring. A time of contrasts, for sure. To add to the already long list of flip-flops you'll encounter this printemps, here's a summary of my recent attempt to clarify something I thought I'd been quite clear on.

Back in February 2006, NASD put out two IM's on Rule 3011, the AML rule for BD's. One of these IM's finally spelled out the independent testing expectations under the Rule. Prior to that, we all made the assumption that testing had to be annual, although it wasn't required in writing at the time. IM-3011-1 explained what 'independent' meant and that testing for most firms was an every-calendar-year requirement. "Most firms" excluded those that didn't execute transactions, hold customer accounts or introduce customers to a clearing firm (act as introducing broker). Well, if you're a prop trading firm with no customers, that's Clariton-clear. If you're a private placement/M&A shop, it's not.

After the Notice came out in 2006, I called and spoke with its author at NASD. My question related to these types of firms--the ones that didn't seem to fit into either category--the poor PP firms that always seem to be denied the benefit of succinct rule interpretation. He explained that PP firms would indeed fall into the 'every year' category. I took him on his word and went ahead and spread that word. My PP clients lived according to this guidance and I saw repeated evidence of District examiners living by this interp, too, since they tested firms for compliance with an annual testing requirement. In conferences, when the subject came up, panelists confirmed it: PP firms were expected to have annual AML testing.

Last week a thick layer of Northeastern pollen settled on this issue. It seems there's dissension in the ranks, that certain examiners are of the opinion that a registered broker-dealer who offers investments in, say, hedge funds, should not be held to the annual testing requirement. General terms, like 'no retail customers,' and 'no brokerage accounts' are being tossed about like old, wet leaves. The well-worn "every firm is different" flag is brought out of winter storage and the conversation is over. My attempt to get into specifics fails. Specifics like: what, exactly, does "execute transactions" mean in this context? What about the apparent contradiction of requiring PP firms to do CIP work while putting them in the category of two-year cycle firms like prop traders, who don't have to do CIP work? How about the fact that FinCEN recently withdrew its proposed AML rules for both IA's and unregistered investment companies? Why? Partly because the financial transactions conducted with these firms have to go through registered BD's--and are thus subject to existing BSA AML requirements. (Doesn't this imply that BD's offering investments in HF's--unregistered investment firms--are presumed to be the front line of AML defense and can be considered to 'execute transactions'?) And lastly, what about the fact that 'corporate' has, seemingly, been clear this subject (Office of General Counsel verbally confirmed last week the continued validity of the annual testing requirement for PP firms). Last week on one call, there was some mention of my profit motive: you know, I stand to make a fortune if my PP firm clients have to have annual instead of bi-annual AML audits. ...aha! now you (and I) know: my passion for regulatory consistency is simply a thinly-veiled construct known as greed. (Note to self: stop spending so much time on this blog entry and get back to the business of manipulating your clients' understanding of their responsibilities.)

Other industry consultants are hip to this muddy subject, too. NRS years ago attempted to have NASD spell it out (they didn't). A savvy consultant in lower Manhattan feels strongly that PP firms don't have to have annual reviews, but suggests that they do, given the ambiguity on the subject. Without specific written guidance on this--or better yet, specific Rule language--different firms will live by different opinions. It seems to me that what is expected is this: you, the small PP/HF offeror firm, have to call your Coordinator and ask him or her which AML exam cycle applies to your particular firm. You may not rely on a generally-accepted, age-old definition of your business activities in order to make a determination using IM-3011-1. Nope. Assume ambiguity and call your District. Without a bright line drawn for all firms, we'll have to find out what FINRA wants, one firm at a time. I, for one, would prefer a different approach.

Yesterday snow flurries blew about the crocus buds. Nature is full of beautiful contradictions. Should securities regulation be so? I'll leave that to the Chauncey Gardeners of the world to contemplate.


[Very important explanatory babble: I really appreciate the dialogue I have with certain FINRA representatives and I don't want that dialogue to end. I believe in their motives and I hope they believe in mine. When I write entries like this, my goal is to assist firms understand misunderstood things and also to promote change to the extent possible. I do not write simply for the sake of complaining or criticizing: for me, it's about making things better. Thanks to those at FINRA who help me do that. --shi]


Friday, March 6, 2009

Sharing SAR's: Some Proposed Changes

FinCEN has announced proposed changes to BSA's regulations on SAR sharing and confidentiality rules. Since they're now just proposals subject to comment, I won't detail every change, but here's my summary:

The guidance on sharing with parent entities will remain intact--it will be built into the regulation so as to be all the more official. Here is the original guidance from January 2006: http://www.fincen.gov/statutes_regs/guidance/html/sarsharingguidance01202006.html You remember that it allowed BD's to share a SAR or the existence of a SAR with a holding or parent company, but not with affiliates. The guidance required that a confidentiality agreement be place with the holding co/parent entity.

BD's will now be allowed to share a SAR or the existence of a SAR with affiliate entities--that is, only if those entities are subject to SAR rules (i.e., banks, BD's, mutual funds, thrifts, insurance co's, casinos, money service business--not IA's or unregistered investment companies). BD's can only share this stuff if they filed the SAR and the affiliates can't go on to share the information with others (it's not like Facebook: 'friends of friends' don't get to see stuff...). Like with parent entities, confidentiality agreements should be in place when sharing with affiliates.

Other changes clarify some things that you might have otherwise assumed, like: the sharing prohibition applies to all employees, directors, agents, etc. (not just the firm); BD's can share SAR's or the existence of SAR's with their examining authorities; and BD's and their employees can share the information, facts, and documents underlying a SAR a) with financial institutions for the sake of filing a joint SAR and b) in connection with certain employment references or termination notices.

I would think FINRA would provide an announcement when these changes go into effect, so look for a Notice in the coming months. For the proposals and guidance, go to: http://www.fincen.gov/statutes_regs/frn/pdf/frnSAR_Confidentiality.pdf and http://www.fincen.gov/statutes_regs/frn/pdf/frnSF_SAR_Sharing.pdf .

Friday, February 20, 2009

Odds and Ends and Others

A few notes to share.

ODD: I have heard that FINRA is issuing deficiency letters to firms that have outside FINOPs if the FINOP is listed as a ‘control person’ on Form BD and if the Form BD doesn’t list every other client firm of that outside FINOP as an affiliate of the firm. So if you're using an outside FINOP, check your Form BD. If he or she is listed as a 'control person' on Schedule A, then under this interpretation, all of his or her other BD clients for whom he or she acts as FINOP must be disclosed as affiliates on Question 10A.

The reasoning (if there is any) would be that all of the entities are under common control by virtue of the outsourced FINOP being a control person of those entities. Obviously, this would unnecessarily and confusingly link completely unrelated firms.

So, the best thing to do is to file a BD amendment, removing your outsourced FINOP as a control person from Schedule A. (Of course, if that person meets the other criteria for being listed on Schedule A--through ownership, for instance--then you'll have to keep him/her listed...but that doesn't seem likely for truly outsourced FINOPs.)

END: The exemption for non-public B-D's from using a PCAOB-registered accounting firm for annual audits is now gone. It expired December 31, 2008. Your 2008 financial statements may be audited by your non-PCAOB firm, but next year is a different matter. You'll have to replace your accounting firm or make sure it got its PCAOB registration before committing to use them for next year's audit. FINRA says it's talking directly to those few firms who have January or February fiscal year-ends.

You may want to work on this before the months evaporate and you find yourself without a registered accounting firm next year. Remember that if you change your accountant you must notify SEC by December 10. Put this on you calendar!

OTHER: FINRA Notice 09-10 describes a change in their treatment of "market letters," which are now a subset of "correspondence" instead of "sales literature." As sales literature, they required pre-approval by a qualified principal--even if sent to institutional investors. Now they are treated like other correspondence and institutional sales material, and their approval requirements will depend on whom they're being sent to and how many are sent within 30 days. You should look to your existing procedures on correspondence and institutional sales material to know which approval processes to follow.

I like this distinction, because it clearly defines those communications not meeting the definition of "research report" that might have otherwise been confused with research reports. For instance, market letters are communications that discuss broad-based indices, include commentaries on economic, political or market conditions, include technical analyses of sectors, indices, or industries, statistical summaries of multiple companies' financial data, including listings of current ratings, present recommendations for increasing or decreasing holdings in particular industries or sectors, or include notices of ratings or price target changes (with certain disclosures).

OTHER: I hear that FINRA will be requiring all firms to update Forms U4 for all representatives, in order to provide answers on some new DRP questions. This will be quite a job for big firms. Stay tuned on this, as no doubt we'll all see a public announcement of the requirement. I'll be helping my clients to manage this process--you will want to make sure you appoint someone to handle it, so you that you avoid reporting deficiencies.

That's it for now. Peace out.

Monday, February 2, 2009

Shame on Who?

I have a "Yes We Can Opener" to commemorate Obama's presidency. I got it at Stupid.com. I'm not ashamed to share that with you (or it with you--c'mon over!). But Mr. Obama is ashamed: of you!

Yes, he's a little upset about the Wall Street bonuses paid for 2008. Well, even though this topic is of no value to you and will not broaden your understanding of current and changing compliance obligations, I feel like talking about it. It's my blog: I'll cry if I want to.

Is the car factory worker to blame for the auto industry's failure? Is the farmhand at fault for the effect of subsidies on our crop market inefficiencies? No. Then why are our brokers blamed for this big financial crisis we're in? Every work day last year these folks got to work by 7:30 or 8:00 a.m. , dressed quite well, by the way, and worked until an hour or two after market closing. They did what was expected of them from on-high: they bought, sold and bartered their way through the day so as to make their bosses happy. They invented or used flashy software tools, trading algorithms and order management systems in order to efficiently get the job done. They did it with skill and enthusiasm...not because they wanted to take down the free market system, but because they wanted to get paid. In their (your) world, they get paid at year-end. They all know it's coming, so they live accordingly. I would do the same. But now comes the end of the world as we know it, and some of us decide to blame the baby in addition to the bath water. What were these legions of Wall Street workers supposed to do? Fall on their superiors' swords? Not expect to get paid for a year's worth of toil and trauma? I don't think so. Yes, they can now all adjust their expectations for 2009: the gig's up. And yes, senior management--the guys/ladies who made the decisions that directly fed our slots-like odds of failure--they should go without their '08 bonuses. They can put their gold in pre-paid envelopes and walk to the post office. Responsibility for this mess falls on those at the top.

Wait, if you're conjuring WWII images, don't. Soldiers know slaughter is wrong; most brokers don't have the tools or knowledge necessary to morally object to their crimes. Or didn't. Now they do. This transition to less fun, less money and great social responsibility will be tough for brokers. I wish you well. And I wish Obama a stronger will to avoid rhetoric.

If you stop by to use my Yes We Can opener, we'll be drinking Iron City. (The Steelers six pack is in the house.)

Friday, November 28, 2008

Update on FACT Act

First, let me share my appreciation for FINRA's effort to explain the applicability of the FACT Act's Red Flag and other rules to member firms. The folks in OGC said they were working on it, and they did. Here's the link to Notice 08-69: http://www.finra.org/web/groups/industry/@ip/@reg/@notice/documents/notices/p117448.pdf

Now, let me express my dismay at the extreme lack of distinct clarity on this topic--not necessarily from FINRA, but embedded in the Act's definitions. Your firm may be subject to the regulation, or not--just read and re-read the definitions of 'financial institution,' 'transaction account, 'creditor' and 'covered account.' It's a little like solving a Rubik's cube. If all like colors end up on the same side, then yes, your firm has to implement Red Flag Rules under the Fact Act. But good luck getting there.

In reading the definitions provided in FINRA's notice, my first reaction is, "If they wanted broker-dealers to be covered, why didn't they just say so?" For instance, the term“financial institution” is specifically defined as “a State or National bank, a State or Federal savings and loan association, a mutual savings bank, a State or Federal credit union, or any other person that, directly or indirectly, holds a transaction account . . . belonging to a consumer.” And a “transaction account” is specifically defined as “a deposit or account on which the depositor or account holder is permitted to make withdrawals by negotiable or transferable instrument, payment orders of withdrawal, telephone transfers, or other similar items for the purpose of making payments or transfers to third persons or others. Such term includes demand deposits, negotiable order of withdrawal accounts, savings deposits subject to automatic transfers, and share draft accounts.” See what I mean? If they wanted B-D's to be subject to the regs, why not just include "SEC registered broker-dealers" or "brokerage accounts" or some such other simple identifiers in the definitions? That would have made it real easy... but instead, these definitions overtly exclude the whole subject of brokerage accounts and broker-dealers. And then your favorite SRO puts the onus on firms to twist and retwist the cube in order to solve the puzzle by themselves. Frankly, for most of the 5100 registered B-D's, I think this is like trying to force a square cube through a round hole: I don't think these rules should apply.

Also, while I'm ranting, this whole thing is crazy!! B-D's already have CIP rules to follow. And remember that AML rules are not just about preventing money laundering. We all know that most AML-triggered investigations end up focusing on fraud, including mail fraud and credit/debit card fraud. So firms are already obligated to attempt to identify and report fraud....why do they have to now be subject to seemingly duplicative rules? And at what cost? ...read the Notice... do you really have time to create a "Written Identity Theft Prevention Program"? One that will confuse your already confused Reps about the account opening process? This reminds me of redundant local ordinances--instead of having one rule that requires safe and responsible behavior on sidewalks, they have in place six different rules, pertaining to different possible ways to conduct unsafe and irresponsible behavior on sidewalks: skateboarding, bicycling, rollerblading, dog walking, etc.... get my point? I guess I just feel sorry for firms whose business has nothing at all to do with credit cards, withdrawals, payment transfers, etc. To think that they will have to adopt lengthy and complicated procedures on top of what they already have in place (which are already hardly deemed necessary and applicable): what a waste of resources.

But who am I ranting at, here? The Federal Trade Commission? That's a big target for a little person like me. And I don't want to trash FINRA--they did something cool by addressing the subject. I guess I would like if FINRA would go a bit farther out on the limb by actually giving its opinion on how application way firms, M&A/PP shops, and introducing firms who do not actually extend margin to clients fit into this definitional puzzle. I know they state up front that they're not the rulemakers or interpreters on this subject, but c'mon, since they go on to say that NOT complying would be a violation of just and equitable principles of trade, can't they show a little more mercy?

Another topic within this one: check out Part C of the Notice. It's about policies you have to have in place re: use of consumer reports. If your firm requests a consumer report about a new or existing customer and receives a notice of address discrepancy from a CRA, you'll have to be able to form a reasonable belief that the consumer report actually relates to the customer in question. FINRA did a nice job of laying out these responsibilities. I'm assuming the effective date of these requirements is the same delayed date as for Red Flag Rules: May 1, 2009 (although I could be wrong.)

Lastly, FINRA mentions in the Notice that FTC has indicated a willingness to work with them to "resolve on a consistent and industry-wide basis, interpretive questions that arise under these rules as applied to broker-dealers. " I love that! My advice to you and all your B-D friends: call OGC at (202)728-8071 to ask about this. Perhaps that kind of dialogue will result in 'interpretive challenges' being met head on with concrete directives from FINRA. Then you can throw that darned Rubik's cube out the window. Puzzle solved.

Friday, November 21, 2008

Networking Rocks!

Big shout out to Christine at IMS. Prompt, thorough assistance on a compliance issue. Gracias, Amiga!

r-e-s-p-e-c-t

...that's what binds both you and me.

I made that rhyme for your auditory pleasure. Say it out loud, go ahead.

I want my clients to know that, not only do I like you, I respect you--that is, I think the work you are doing is hard and you should be praised for that. Many in the media are trashing investment bankers, brokers and bankers, alike, as if they alone are to blame for the market turmoil. We know that's not true. You, my clients, are creative individuals who choose to make a living by making other people money. That ain't no crime. And the more creativity, energy and motivation you have, most likely, the more money your clients will make. (That came out a bit like Yoda-speak.)

Oh, and what I really want to say is thank-you for likewise respecting me and my work. It's an honor to help you out and I benefit everyday from your appreciation for what I do.

Oh my gosh, this touchy feely stuff is hard to take, non? Okay, back to my Rule Conversion/WSP update work...