skip to main |
skip to sidebar
June 1:
>The effective/enforcement date of FTC's Red Flags Rule, whereby you, my broker-dealer friends, had to put in place an Identity Theft Prevention Program.
>The date by which I (against my better judgment/procrastination instincts) worked my buttocks off in an attempt to customize/deliver FTC's neat-o PDF customizable 'low-risk' form.
>The date before which, if a regulatory body were going to announce a delay in enforcement of the Rule, said regulatory body should have announced a delay of said Rule.
June 2:
>The date after which you, my broker-dealer friends, put into effect your IDTPP's, after having struggled to customize either FINRA's template or FTC's 'customizable low-risk form.
>The date after which we all collectively considered this topic done/handled/put to rest and happily forgotten about it.
>The date we got notice from FINRA that the enforcement date of the Rule had been delayed AGAIN...now to Dec. 31, 2010.
>The date, perhaps, you and I both swore under our breath something profane and un-American.
Here is the announcement, in case you missed it:
The FTC has again delayed enforcement of its Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act of 2003 (FACT Act) Red Flags Rule, from June 1, 2010, to December 31, 2010. The delay will allow Congress to consider legislation limiting the businesses covered by the rule. If legislation passes with an effective date earlier than December 31, 2010, the FTC will begin enforcement as of that effective date.
Firms subject to this rule—which include most broker-dealers—must have in place by the FTC enforcement date a written program to identify, detect and respond to patterns, practices or specific activities that could indicate identity theft.
As a reminder, FINRA has developed an optional template that firms may use as a guide when fulfilling their requirements under the FTC's Red Flags Rule. You can find more information about the FACT Act regulations in Regulatory Notice 08-69.
I won't start babbling about how I think this Rule is redundant and how the criteria for determining applicability is being interpreted in a bogus way. You can always search the subject on my blog to read more. But why bother? Let's just forget this all happened. And let's hope the Rule NEVER gets enforced for you BD's who are already, under AML rules, required to act as law enforcement and root out any nefarious attempts to usurp identities (even if they're not terrorists).
What a Difference a Day Makes: No, what a difference two weeks would have made! Now that kind of lead-time would have been appreciated! (Here I am again, Daydream Believer.)
Just commenting on some miscellaneous topics. Variety is the spice of life.
S(M)ocialware: The company "Socialware" (which recently partnered with Smarsh) offers compliance tools for social media. If you are brave enough to allow your Reps to use tools like Linked In, Facebook and Twitter to expand their business, then you should check out this vendor's products. As you know, archiving and monitoring those types of communications is required, and, the fact that I am an ITiot, I can't fathom managing that compliance without some sophisticated help. I see on their website that they will be at the May FINRA conference in Baltimore. Check'em out when you're there. (PS: Here's a link to a free, interactive webcast on the topic of advisers using social media sites as business communication tools... June 2 webcast).
E?-Learning: Let me commence by stating unequivocally that the people who work in FINRA's E-Learning department are wonderful---> helpful, dedicated, pleasant. I appreciate them with my entire being. [pause] BUT: oh-em-gee. Having just gone through the process of setting up a firm's reps for participation in E-Learning in order to meet C/E firm element assignments, I have to surmise that the regulatory body formerly known as NASD did not do proper due diligence when choosing a programmer for their newly (?)improved FINRA Education online system. From start to finish, the system is crazily inefficient and cumbersome. To choose "Mandatory" for an assigned course, you can't just type the word, or choose it from a drop down menu--instead, you have to click/search/type/click/etc. before the magic word "Mandatory" appears in the box. Adding courses to a Rep's training plan is equally puzzle-like...instead of a list or drop down menu to choose from, you have to search for specific course names. I have more nit-picks but this is getting boring...take it from me, give yourself mucho time to set up Reps' training plans if you intend to use this system. And don't blame our friends at E-Learning: they really are great.
Report C/Enter: FINRA now offers a 'continuing education regulatory element report' on Report Center. It is a quarterly report that shows how your firm's Reps perform on Reg. Element testing, compared to industry averages. You may want to incorporate this report into your C/E needs analysis process. Check it out on Report Center in Firm Gateway (you won't see a report listed if there were no Reps who took Reg. Element training in the prior quarter).
Proposed Rule 20Fuzzy: --'er, I mean, 2040. See Notice 09-69 for a description of the proposed rule, which concerns payments to unregistered persons. What everyone is always hoping for is crisp rule language on paying people like finders. For now, it's fuzzy, and according to the Notice and thoughtful comment letters, it will remain so. I suggest you read a few of the comment letters, like the one from NASAA and the one from Morgan, Lewis, to understand how this Rule, as proposed, will provide no clarity on this issue. (Wanna pay an unregistered finder? Hire a legal team to prepare an opinion of counsel that, by relying on specific regulatory guidance, no-action letters and interpretations [not rules, mind you!], justifies how your payment will not subject the recipient to SEC registration. ...G'luck with that.)
Gee, I wish I weren't so critical, cynical, analytical and generally bitch-ical. But seriously, can you blame me?? Enjoy your sunshine and your weekend--may it be varied and spicy.
I'm so happy I started this process seven months in advance. By December, I should know how to properly customize SEC's new "model form" privacy notice (see earlier blog entries). Reminders: here is the link to the site with the links to the model forms--Form Builder Site; and here is the link to instructions for customizing the forms.
The forms are a great idea and would be very useful IF they didn't create substantial frustration when attempting to fill them in. Certain fields don't accept the information you want to include; other fields are too small to accept your chosen disclosures; lines or fields that may be omitted (according to the instructions) can't be; and, well, I generally fear that small firms not well-versed in Reg. S-P and the Fact Act will not be able to customize the form correctly. On the "Reasons" table, is the answer Yes? or No?...situations where your affiliate IA markets to your BD customers using information you shared with it will necessitate considerations like, "Is the BD subject to the Fact Act?", "Is the IA subject to the Fact Act?" and "Does the affiliate use personal information in a manner that requires an opt out?" Will micro firms know the answers? Will they even know the questions? Probably not. It's complicated stuff. And despite what the SEC thinks--that firms are supposed to be familiar with these rules (that's a paraphrase from my convo this morning)--you and I both know only the firms with the big-budget legal teams can feel good about what's in the fine print.
The form, quite simply, is not a user-friendly, prompt-driven tool for small BD's without legal departments or idle word processors. I wish it were, it would save me time, too. But instead, I just spent all day creating Word documents with input fields (big enough fields!) and comments (explaining the choices) so that I can help my clients adopt and complete the form without seriously profane outbursts (a friendly, grateful shout out to KN, whose "bite me!" did indeed fit into an SEC input field with no problem).
If anyone wants my Word forms, write me. I may accept modest remuneration for my efforts.
Oh, and perhaps you should think about using your old Privacy Notice, instead. My next research project is to understand completely what changed in Reg. S-P and how much effort it would take to simply revise my clients' existing forms. The dangling 'safe harbor' carrot presented by the Model Form may not be enough, in the end. Warn Bugs if you see him.
Now that I'm no longer watching C-SPAN 3's version of The Good, The Bad and The Ugly, here are a few reminders about real regulatory matters that are not being debated anywhere on TV:
INVESTMENT BANKERS: Remember: if you are an investment banker you can opt-in to the new IB exam by filing a U4 amendment instead of taking the Series 79 exam. But you only have until May 3 to do it! See my July 30, 2009, entry for the details.
PRIVATE PLACEMENTS: For those of you doing private placements, check out Notice 10-22. The Notice, in my opinion, does not go as far as it should in clarifying expectations. It remains vague and incomplete. A few comments: they lay the responsibility for the PP Memorandum on the firm that prepared it or assisted in its preparation, but expect you to fill in any holes if you perceive them; if you didn’t prepare the PPM, you still have responsibility for any sales literature you distribute, whether or not you prepared it; and you may rely on counsel or syndicate managers to prepare the PPM and do due diligence, as long as you have confidence in that third party (and have documented your vetting process). Oh, and yes, you have to determine suitability of your investors—even if they are accredited. You already knew that, but now it’s official.
The Notice includes a list of due diligence topics. For those of you putting together offerings and charged with this responsibility, it would be behoove you to review the list to make sure you are currently addressing these areas of investigation.
PRIVACY NOTICES: As I noted in my January 28, 2010, entry, SEC has put out a 'model form' to use as your privacy notice. There are difference versions, depending on opt-out options. Here is a link to SEC’s newly released Privacy Form Builder. This site provides links to the different model forms. If you do not use the model form, which assures safe harbor if customized correctly, then you must make sure your privacy notice conforms to Reg. S-P changes by year-end.
...and havin' a blast! Yes, I'm spending my day watching the Goldman hearing. I didn't plan to do this, it just happened. But I'm sure glad it worked out this way. I vacillate between hating the senators and hating the GS kids. And between loving the senators and loving the boys. Sometimes the conversation looks like my 17-year-old son trying to explain the difference between the music of Lil Wayne and P. Diddy to an 85-year-old Belarusian who speaks no English. The knowledge divide is immense! But there's plenty of CYA and political rhetoric to go around, that's for sure. I respect Mr. Sparks' attempts to explain the complexities of the market to his elders; I like Mr. Tourre's willingness to not rest on legalese; I get a huge kick out the predictability of Mr. Birnbaum's CYA-speak (he wins in this event); and the exasperated brevity of Mr. "Um"'s (forgot his name) responses. There's nothing new about this showdown and it was very easy to explain it to my teenage boys (who watched with me for quite a while, much to my surprise): I mean, c'mon, politicians expressing disbelief and anger at these apparently unethical, greedy players versus slick, coached, extremely experienced and smart professionals defending their daily grind and covering for their employers?...not hard to explain. They could be speaking Farsi and we'd all still get it.
My problem is, I see both sides. I respect the skill of Wall Street bartenders, but I, like many, have suffered thanks to their concoctions. They made great lemonade, as Mr. Sparks said, but it was folks like me and my neighbors that were left to suck the lemon rinds.
And yet, can I trust our DC reps to sort this out and come up with the best answer? I'm not that drunk..
Or is it our bottom five suspicious states?
FinCEN's "By The Numbers" report from January shows SAR-SF reporting summary totals from 2003 through June 2009. SAR-SF's are forms filed by securities brokerage firms and other non-depository institutions (non-banks). Here are the states with our nation's most trusting brokers (or most honest investors, depending on how you look at it), in order of fewest SAR-SF's filed since 2003:
- Alaska (!! How can they be that unsuspicious? Is there no check fraud, mail fraud, insider trading, or at very least, forgery, taking place up there? I'm suspicious...)
- Wyoming (1 SAR-SF filed since 2003 for check fraud. I hope it was against Cheney.)
- Hawaii (5 total: 1 for embezzlement and the others for other... you can't trust surfers...or maybe you can...)
- Rhode Island (twice the population of Wyoming living on 1/100 the land mass and only 4 more SAR-SFs? Obviously the most trusting lot on the East Coast. We should all move there.)
- South Dakota (Hmmm. How can they have filed 10 SAR-SF's to date more than Alaska, a state full of corrupt politicians and crazed hunters with helicopters? I'm still suspicious...)
I skipped non-states in my list, such as District of Columbia. DC beat SD with fewer SAR-SFs. WHAT?? Wait, DC has 600,000 people living there, most of them working for the government (okay, that might not be technically true), and these numbers make it look like Mayberry RFD. What do these numbers mean: are there no BD's, CPO's, CTA's, FCM's, IA's or other such financial institutions in DC, resulting in the dearth of filings? Or is everyone in DC really, really honest, their activities arousing no suspicions? (Uh, did I just say that?) Or does everyone in DC have each other's backs?--oh wait, I may have stumbled onto something. Hmmm. Again, I'm suspicious.
Oh, in case you're wondering, NY has the highest number of SAR-SF's filed to date. Ho hum.
And once again, the type of suspicious activity near the bottom (ranked 20 out of 21) is--yes, that's right--Terrorist Financing! The reason you're all in this mess called AML compliance represents less than 1% of all SAR-SF's filed to date--206, to be exact. The SAR Activity Review offers a lot of information on the growth of mortgage loan fraud as a reported event, but nothing on how all these SAR's are fighting terrorism. But then again, we now know that it's not about that anymore.
________________________
As for bankers and their customers: completely different story. Alaska redeems itself in that race, with the second highest number of SAR's filed from 1996 through June 2009. Now that's what I'm talkin' about! Wyoming is still pretty unsuspicious, ranking 48th out of the 50 states (but that doesn't absolve Cheney of my personal suspicion); and surfers, believe it or not, turn out to not be so trustworthy (Hawaii ranks 30th). South Dakota (23rd) has thousands more SAR filings by banks, but still looks good compared to Alaska; and lastly, I still think it's a good idea to move to Rhode Island...38th of the 50 states.
The good news for New Yorkers is that California outdid them in the SAR's-filed-by-banks competition: CA has more than double NY's filings.
And yes, Terrorist Financing ranks equally low in these filings, just like with SAR-SF's: second to last with less than 1% of all filings. Sigh.
_________________________
Here are the links to my resources. I suggest you take a look, so you can glean useful information (as opposed to useless information like the kind I presented above). The last link is especially valuable for you AML Compliance Officers and auditors.
FinCEN's News Release on the Jan. 2010 By The Numbers Report
FinCEN's SAR Activity Review--By The Numbers Jan. 2010
FinCEN's SAR Activity Review, October 2009
Having survived a wind storm and a semi-annual procedures update process that nearly killed me (the update, not the wind storm), I am resurfacing to provide a few reminders:
1. R.I.P. Webcasts: After March 31 you will no longer be able to view Webcasts on FINRA's website. All of the prior content is included in other offerings, such as Video E-Learning or plain-old E-Learning courses. But, well, you have to pay for those. Webcasts were free. All's fair in love, war, and a crappy economy.
2. TRACE: Agency Debt Securities became TRACE eligible on March 1, as did certain primary market transactions (those that qualify as list or fixed price offering or takedown transactions). See Notice 09-57.
3. New Capital Compliance Rule: As of February 8, the new financial responsibility rules became effective (FINRA Rules 4110, etc.). Many of the restrictive rules apply to "carrying or clearing firms"--but look at the footnote in the rule and you'll see that they also apply to firms with "k2i" accounts--you know, the account you have set up so you can receive checks from customers for mutual fund and other purchases? This new rule requires, for instance, that your firm must obtain prior written approval before withdrawing any capital that exceeds10 percent of the firm’s excess net capital in any rolling 35-calendar-day period. This includes withdrawals of profits, routine dividends and similar distributions. Wow. For small business owners who take profits this way, this rule seems extremely onerous. See Notice 09-71.
As for the answers to these extremely logical questions: 1) "To whom do firms request approval?" and 2) "How long does FINRA have to grant approval?", well, the answers were not easy to find... in summary: 1) Eventually there will be an electronic request process on Gateway, but for now fax or email your District Office, and 2) In your communication to the District, inform them that you will be making the distribution in x days in the absence of a response from them. In the published Response to Comments on these rules, it states,"[...] requests for withdrawals can be handled in a routine manner and that decisions typically would be issued in approximately three business days": how's that for clarity?!
[Allow me for a moment to express frustration with FINRA for making a Rule effective without having a mechanism in place for allowing firms to comply with the Rule--and for not providing this basic, administrative information to all firms in an easily accessible, publicly-available place (like the Notice??), rather than burying (half of) it in filing documents not regularly visited by most compliance staff. And what-up with making pleasant, good-intentioned, helpful folks like moi feel wrong for asking presumably easy questions and expecting to get answers? What's wrong with regulators saying, "I don't know" or "We're still working on that" or "Three days, but sorry, we didn't put that in the Notice"? ... ugh. P.S. I'm thankful to Estee Dorfman Foster (CPA/outsourced FINOP) for her assistance in finding answers.]
4. Variable Annuity Rules: As of February 8, the formerly-delayed parts of FINRA Rule 2330 became effective. Principals now have 7 days to review recommended v/a purchases and exchanges. There are changes to customer funds rules, too--because if you held a customer's check during that 7 days, you would have otherwise broken SEC customer funds rules. Check out Notice 10-05 for fresh guidance on these changes.
5. AML Madness: FINRA released its updated AML Small Firms Template in January... it is full of wonderfully--wait, not wonderfully, but rather, dreadfully--legalistic text changes that would drive any technical writer crazy. I'm proud to say my template is still better than theirs. You should look at your AML program and FINRA's updated template to assess the time it will take to make corresponding changes; then you should drown your sorrows in a stiff drink (or call me!). See here for a link to the template in Word format. Oh and remember that as of January 1, you may no longer have someone in your small firm conduct annual independent testing if that person has a conflict of interest (you used to be able to rely on a loophole--it is gone). For this rule change, see Notice 09-60.
6. 3012/3130--Testing & Verification: For most of you, it's that time of year again--in fact, this is the 5th time you have to follow these rules since inception! This should be easy by now...You have to test and verify your supervisory system. And write a report. And write another report about the process of writing the report. And sign a certification. And put the whole shebang in a file drawer and hope no-one ever asks for it (...but they will). Remember, your reports and certifications are due w/in 12 months of last year's. It's not a calendar year requirement--it's every 12 months by the anniversary. Here is a link to regulatory information on supervisory controls.
7. Short Sales Rule Change: Mary over at SEC approved a change to Reg. SHO, affectionately called the "alternative uptick rule" that restricts short selling in stocks that have dropped 10% in price in one day. Effective Date: May 10, 2010; Compliance Date: November 10, 2010. See link to Reg SHO change for 334 pages of bedtime reading. I'm getting sleepy just thinking about it.
8. TARP Warrants: How do we describe these nouvelles choses? Warrants (that's what they're called)? Options (they're priced like options)? Corporate securities (they're issued by corp's)? Government securities (they were issued to Uncle Sam--is he backing them in the secondary market)? Ask 4 people and you'll get 4 different answers (ask me and you'll get a frustrated shrug of confusion and disgust). Stay tuned for the answer.
FINRA has released its March 1 examination priorities. Review it and weep. You have work to do.
Your Moment of Optimism: 17 days till Spring!